Volume 4, No. 2, Summer 1993 |
General Announcements
Nobel Conference XXVIX, at Gustavus Adolphus College, Saint Peter, Minnesota
will be held October 5-6, on the theme "Nature Out of Balance: The
New Ecology." Arne Naess was the previously announced philosophy speaker,
but has had to cancel due to reasons of health and Bryan G. Norton, Georgia
Institute of Technology, replaces him. The other speakers, all scientists,
are: Daniel Botkin, University of California, Santa Barbara; Jared M. Diamond,
UCLA School of Medicine; Thomas Lovejoy, Smithsonian Institution; Robert
May, University of Oxford; Donella Meadows, Dartmouth University; and George
M. Woodwell, Wood's Hole Oceanographic Institute. This is the only conference
outside Europe authorized by the Nobel Foundation of Stockholm. For more
details contact Nobel Conference XXVIX, Gustavus Adolphus College, 800 West
College Avenue, Saint Peter, MN 56082. Phone 507/933-7550.
The Royal Institute of Philosophy 1993 Conference, "Philosophy and
the Natural Environment," is at the University of Wales College of
Cardiff, July 20-23. Speakers are listed in the ISEE Newsletter, Spring
93. Contact Robin Attfield and Andrew Belsey, Philosophy Section, University
of Wales College of Cardiff, P. O. Box 94, Cardiff CF1 3XE, UK.
The 19th World Congress of Philosophy, meets in Moscow, August 22- 28, 1993.
ISEE has organized a session on environmental ethics, one a roundtable discussion.
Anticipated participants in the two sessions: include Karen Warren (Macalester
College), James Sterba (University of Notre Dame), Holmes Rolston (Colorado
State University), Laura Westra (University of Windsor), Willem Landman
(University of the Western Cape, South Africa), Avner de-Shalit (Political
Science, Hebrew University, Jerusalem), Yrjo SepÑnmaa (University
of Helsinki), Donald VandeVeer (North Carolina State University), Brad Marden
and Eric Hol (Environmental Protection Agency). Obtaining visas has proved
to be troublesome for participants, who have to prepay all hotel bills before
they depart, and have to verify where they will be during each night of
stay in Russia. For congress information and registration contact World
Congress of Philosophy, EGA Studio, Viale Tiziano 19, Rome, Italy. Fax (06)
32-22-006.
The Fifth World Wilderness Congress will be held in Tromso, Norway, September
24-October 1, 1993. There is an ISEE sponsored session, "The Idea of
the Wild." Speakers: Lois Lorentzen, "Reminiscing about a Sleepy
Lake: Women and Wilderness in El Salvador"; Max Oelschlaeger, "The
Idea of Wilderness as a Deep Ecological Ethic"; Nils Faarlund, "Silence
and the Wild"; Dusty Gruver, "The Philosopher/Gardener";
Douglas Buege, "Taking Inuit Knowledge Seriously: Responsible Knowing
in the Canadian Arctic"; Melissa Nelson, "Ten Tribes in Northern
California: A Case Study of Wilderness Management"; Richard Gale, "The
New Forestry: How Wild the Welcome Mat?"; Marvin Henberg, "Wilderness:
The Possibility of a Pancultural View"; "Elisabeth Carlessare,
"Love Your Mother: The Wild in Planet Earth"; Laura Westra, "Ecosystem
Integrity and Sustainability: The Foundational Value of Wilderness";
David Abram, "Wild Culture and the Word"; David Rothenberg, "The
Idea of the North"; Robert Greenway, "Wilderness Therapy";
Leena Vilkka, "Intrinsic Value and the Wild"; Peder Anker, "Deep
Ecology Put To the Test"; Ville Hallikainen, "The Finnish Concept
of Wilderness"; Myrdene Anderson, "The Polysemy of Wild";
Mikel Vause, "Knights of Nothingness"; Andrew Light, "The
Urban Wilderness." Thanks to David Rothenberg for convening the session.
Contact him for information on the ISEE Session. Department of Humanities,
New Jersey Institute of Technology, Newark, NJ 07102. Phone 201/596-3289.
Fax 201/565-0586. For information on Congress attendance, contact The Wild
Foundation, 211 W. Magnolia, Fort Collins, CO 80521. Phone 303/498-0303.
"Ecosystem Integrity and Policy: International Issues," to be
held in Washington, November 10-13, coordinated with Mark Sagoff's Center
for Philosophy and Public Policy and the Environmental Management of Enclosed
Coastal Seas Conference. See events, below.
The International Society for Value Inquiry meets August 14-16 in Helsinki,
followed by the Tenth International Social Philosophy Conference, August
17-20. Some papers at the latter: Robin Attfield (Philosophy, University
of Wales, Cardiff), "Population Growth and Hope for Humanity";
Karen Warren, "Ecofeminist Spiritualities: What Should an Ecofeminist
Think?"; W. Donner (Carleton University, Ottawa), "Inherent Value,
Self, and Community in Environmental Ethics"; Laura Westra, "Human
Rights in the Third World, Global Sustainability and Environmental Racism";
James Sterba (Philosophy, University of Notre Dame), "Environmental
Justice."
Ethical issues in hunting. Steven J. Bissell, who is chief of environmental
interpretation for the Colorado Division of Wildlife, completed spring 1993
a Ph.D. dissertation, ETHICAL ISSUES IN STATE WILDLIFE POLICY: A QUALITATIVE
ANALYSIS, through the Graduate School of Public Affairs of the University
of Denver. Lloyd Burton was the principal advisor. Bissell documented in
a series of focus group interviews in five states that the state wildlife
commissions and agencies are often considerably out of touch with the values
that are held both by contemporary hunter and nonhunter citizens, catering
to a rather narrow interest group of traditional hunters. His analysis concludes
that if both citizens and agency personnel were to take Aldo Leopold's land
ethic more seriously, much of this value gap would be alleviated. Case studies
involve are: Colorado and California black bear hunting; Arizona elk hunting
(using hunters to cull a herd, biological necessity of the hunt; equity
in a hunting lottery); Pennsylvania wild turkey hunting (hunters refusing
to wear safety colors); deer hunting in New Hampshire (hunters preferring
too many deer for the habitat). Bissell can be contacted at the Colorado
Division of Wildlife, 6060 Broadway, Denver, CO 80216. Phone 303/291-7267.
Shigeyuki Okajima is an editorial writer for environmental affairs with
THE YOIMURI SHIMBUM, a Tokyo based Japanese newspaper, and was in the spring
a 1993 Eisenhower Fellow from Japan, researching environmental ethics in
the United States. THE YOMIURI SHIMBUN has a total daily circulation of
15 million (morning and evening editions) and also publishes a daily English
edition of 50,000 copies. Eisenhower Exchange Fellowships, funded both by
private endowments and by the U. S. Congress, bring about two dozen internationals
into the United States each year to study current trends in the United States
that can prove beneficial to foreign countries. In addition to being a distinguished
journalist in Japan, Shigeyuki Okajima has written a book introducing the
Japanese to American environmentalism (listed in recent books, below), and
an introduction to American environmentalism for Japanese high school students,
in English, used to teach both English and environmentalism. He is also
an ornithologist and alpinist, active in bird conservation in Japan. He
has climbed to the 24,000 foot level of Mount Everest. He hopes to bring
American insights to bear on Japanese problems, and to work toward joining
American and Japanese national policies toward solving global environmental
problems. Two of interests are John Muir and spiritual and philosophical
attitudes toward nature. In 1988 he was given the Global 500 Award from
the United Nations Environment Programme. Address: Shigeyuki Okajima, THE
YOMIURI SHIMBUN, 1-7- 1, Ohtemachi Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo, Japan 100-55.
The University of Minnesota Press announces a new series, MONOGRAPHS IN
BIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION, seeking innovative, book- length manuscripts
that blend the scientific and social disciplines necessary to shape a science
of conservation that will mitigate the erosion of biological diversity from
the Earth. They are interested in works that make environmental ethics applicable
to the conservation of biodiversity. Larry D. Harris, in forest resources
and conservation at the University of Florida, is the series editor. For
more information contact Barbara Coffin, Natural and Environmental Sciences
Editor, The University of Minnesota Press, 2037 University Avenue, S. E.,
Minneapolis, MN 55414-3092. Phone 612/624-7368.
PEACE REVIEW invites papers, especially for a special issue, "Development,
Environment, and Human Rights," deadline May 1, 1994. Send essays on
disk to Professor Robert Elias, University of San Francisco, 2130 Fulton
St., San Francisco, CA 94117-1080. Phone: 415/ 666-6349.
At the Society for Conservation Biology, Arizona State University, Tempe,
on Friday, June 11 there was an ISEE session, organized by Jack Weir. Moderator:
Joan L. McGregor (Philosophy, Arizona State University). Papers: Holmes
Rolston, III (Philosophy, Colorado State University), "Who Owns Wild
Species?"; Edwin P. Pister (Desert Fishes Council), "Ethical Concerns
in the Conservation of Biodiversity"; Richard Shearman (Environmental
Studies, Rochester Institute of Technology), "The Virtue of Preserving
Species Diversity" (based on an Aristotelian approach); Laura Westra
(Philosophy, University of Windsor) and James Kay (Environment and Resource
Studies, University of Waterloo), "Ecosystem Integrity Reconsidered";
and Jack Weir, "Case Reasoning, Intuitions, and Pluralism in Environmental
Ethics." Also in the general program: Holmes Rolston, "Biological
Conservation After the Earth Summit." In a presidential address, outgoing
president Stanley A. Temple (Wildlife Ecology, University of Wisconsin,
Madison) noted that the most significant issues that the Society faces are
philosophical and ethical.
The Wildlands Project drew considerable advocacy and argument at the Society
for Conservation Biology, covered in a subsequent writeup in SCIENCE. This
plan, launched by Dave Foreman, formerly with Earth First! seeks large core
areas of wildlands conserved, buffer zones, and corridors between these.
Reed Noss, the incoming editor of CONSERVATION BIOLOGY, is one of the architects
of the project, as is Michael SoulÇ, who argued, at the meeting that
wildness need to be big, fierce, and dangerous. Edward O. Wilson and Paul
Ehrlich also endorse the project. On the Oregon coast, the plan wants about
25% of the land in wilderness and about 25% in buffer zones. Another high
wildness area is the Southern Appalachians. See a special issue of WILD
EARTH, "The Wildlands Project." Deborah Jensen, director of conservation
science for the Nature Conservancy, wants more wilderness, but complained,
"Frankly, this whole business about wildness being fierce is a male
thing." She also thinks that the project expects to move many people
from their homes, when a better plan helps people live compatibly with the
biodiversity around them. The SCIENCE story is predictably establishmentarian,
"The High Cost of Biodiversity," 25 June, 1993. "A controversial
plan to protect North American biodiversity calls for nothing less than
resettling the continent. That may be too much to ask of the people who
already live there."
The Society for Conservation Biology meets next year, June 1994, in Guadalajara,
Mexico, at the Universidad de Guadalajara. ISEE will sponsor a session;
papers dealing with environment and development in Latin America or the
Third World are especially encouraged. Contact Jack Weir, Morehead State
University.
The International Chamber of Commerce has produced two short documents,
"Environmental Guidelines for World Industry" (1990) and "The
Business Charter for Sustainable Development" (1990).
They are available in several languages. The ICC also maintains a Commission
on Environment and an International Environmental Bureau. Contact the International
Chamber of Commerce, 38, Cours Albert 1er, 75008 Paris, France. Tel 49.53.28.27.
Fax 42-25-86- 63.
Evangelical Christians and the Environment. About forty scientists and theologians
met Friday, July 2, in Oxford, England, to plan action based on a document,
"Evangelical Christianity and the Environment," produced by the
World Evangelical Fellowship's Theological Commission on Ethics and Society.
Participants included Ghillean Prance, Director of the Royal Botanic Gardens,
Kew, R. J. Berry, Professor of Genetics at University College, London, Calvin
DeWitt, Director of the Au Sable Institute, and others. One activity is
the International Evangelical Environmental Network, with contacts around
the globe. Contact: R. C. J. Carling, Chapman and Hall, 2-6 Boundary Row,
London, SE1 8HN. Tel 865-0066, ext. 6772; Fax 522-9621.
"Nature and Environment" was a section of the Philosophy, Interpretation,
Culture Conference, SUNY, Binghamton, Binghamton, New York, April 16-17.
Papers: Doug Daigle (Colorado State University), "The Role of a Planetary
Narrative in Environmental Ethics"; Phil Lewin (Clarkson University),
"Science, Difference, Nature"; R. Read (Rutgers University), "Culture,
Nature, ENVIRONMENT: The Priority of Environmental Ethics to Epistemology
and Metaphysics."
United Nations Conference on Ethical Issues in Agenda 21, January 20-21,
1994. The Conference will be held at the United Nations Building, United
Nations Plaza, New York, NY. Contact Donald Brown, Ethics Research Group,
2915 Beverly Road, Camp Hill, PA 17011 (near Harrisburg). Fax 717/787-9379.
University presses are turning more and more to general-interest books,
provided they can both appeal to general readers and maintain scholarly
standards--partly to fill a vacuum left by trade publishers who are less
and less interested in books on which they cannot make considerable profit,
regardless of their content and competence. Many presses are particularly
interested in environmental concerns because of their relevance and their
broad audiences. Some samples: Christopher D. Stone, THE GNAT IS OLDER THAN
MAN: GLOBAL ENVIRONMENT AND HUMAN AGENDA (Princeton); Donald Worster, THE
WEALTH OF NATURE: ENVIRONMENTAL HISTORY AND THE ECOLOGICAL IMAGINATION (Oxford);
George B. Schaller, THE LAST PANDA (Chicago) on all three see below) and
Holmes Rolston, CONSERVING NATURAL VALUE (Columbia, forthcoming), and others
in the recent books section below. Story in CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITOR, June
4, 1993.
The George H. Gallup International Institute has released a report of results
from its 1992 "Health of the Planet" Survey. Based on personal
interviews with over 30,000 citizens in 24 nations, the survey examines
a wide range of environmental perceptions, especially international environmental
issues, including sustainable development. The results reveal a remarkably
high level of awareness and concern about environmental problems among citizens
of all nations, both rich and poor, as well as less disagreement on the
causes and solutions than is commonly assumed to exist between residents
of the rich and poor nations. Authored by Riley E. Dunlap, George H. Gallup,
Jr., and Alec M. Gallup, the 160 page report is available from the George
H. Gallup International Institute, 47 Hulfish Street, Princeton, NJ 08542.
Phone 609/921-6200. Academics and representatives of public interest groups
can obtain copies at a discounted price of $ 25.00.
The George Wright Society FORUM calls for papers for the winter 1993-94
issue, on sustainability and environmental ethics. The FORUM is an international
journal, published quarterly to promote stewardship of resources in protected
areas and on public lands. Deadline for manuscripts is October 1. Contact
Geoffrey M. Swan, Joseph C. Dunstan, or Katherine L. Jope, all at National
Park Service, Pacific Northwest Region, 83 South King Street, Suite 212,
Seattle, WA 98104. Phone 206/553-1006 or 553-5670.
For computerized environmentalists, there is a newsletter going out of Valdosta
State University, Valdosta, Georgia. There is a mixture of debate and conversation,
recently on the ethics of wilderness rescues and on intrinsic value in nature
(some twenty exchanges, including transatlantic contributions). To subscribe,
send electronic mail to: listserv@catfish.valdosta.peachnet.edu. In the
body of the message, type: sub cpae yourname. This means subscribe to the
newsletter of the Center for Professional and Applied Ethics, a center at
Valdosta State University. Your own electronic mail address will automatically
be included in the mail sent. Two philosophers involved there are Ari Santas
(asantas@grits.valdosta.peachnet.edu) (Internet) and Ron Barnette (rbarnett@grits.valdosta.peachnet.edu)
(Internet).
Douglas J. Buege has volunteered to compile a list of E-mail address for
members of ISEE. Send him your E-mail address. Douglas J. Buege, 355 Ford
Hall, Department of Philosophy, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN
55455. <bueg0002@student.tc.umn.edu>. He is also interested in references
on degree of organic unity as a basis for value.
THE NORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL JOURNAL invites manuscripts on environmental
issues important to Western North America, exploring the environmental dimensions
of the natural and social sciences, policy, business, law, ethics, and education.
The journal focuses on the Pacific Northwest, but especially seeks analyses
that offer insights beyond regional boundaries. Contact the editors, James
R. Karr and Ellen W. Chu, NORTHWEST ENVIRONMENTAL JOURNAL, Engineering Annex,
FM-12, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195. Phone 206/543-1812.
Fax: 206/543-2025. Karr is known for his work defining biological integrity
in ecosystems; Chu was formerly editor of BIOSCIENCE.
Eastern Division, American Philosophical Association, meets Dec. 27-30,
1993 in Atlanta, GA, at the Atlanta Marriott. ISEE Session on the theme:
New Directions in Environmental Ethics. Robert Gottlieb (Worcester Polytechnic
Institute), "Whose Life Is it Anyway?: Ecology/Identity/Politics";
Kelly Parker (Grand Valley State University), "Pragmatism and Environmental
Thought"; chaired by Eric Katz (New Jersey Institute of Technology).
Central Division, American Philosophical Association, meets May 5- 7, 1994
in Kansas City. Papers are still invited for one ISEE session. Submit proposals
to Professor Laura Westra, Department of Philosophy, University of Windsor,
Windsor, Ontario N9B 3P4, Canada. Phone: 519/253-4232 (2342). Fax: 519/973-7050.
Another session will be on "Ethics and Radioactive Waste," with
participants, Patricia Flemming (Philosophy, Creighton University, Omaha),
"Circularity and Regulatory Policy: The Case of Yucca Mountain";
Kristin Shrader-Frechette (Philosophy, University of South Florida), "Nuclear
Waste and Free Informed Consent: The Case of Yucca Mountain," with
commentator, Craig Walton (Philosophy, University of Nevada, Las Vegas).
Pacific Division meets March 31-April 2, 1994, in Los Angeles. Submit proposals
to Professor James Heffernan, Department of Philosophy, College of the Pacific,
University of the Pacific, 3601 Pacific Avenue, Stockton, CA 95211. Phone:
209/946-2281. PLEASE NOTE THIS CHANGE FROM ERNEST PARTRIDGE, WHO WAS PREVIOUSLY
RECEIVING THESE PROPOSALS.
In general the annual deadlines for paper submissions for the three ISEE
sessions regularly held at the three divisional American Philosophical Association
meetings are:
Eastern Division, March 1
Central Division, January 1, proposals by October 15
Pacific Division, January 1, proposals by October 15
Robert Elliot is the contact person for Australia and New Zealand. Send
membership forms and dues in amount $ 15.00 Australian ($ 7.50 for students)
to him. Address: Department of Philosophy, University of New England, Armidale,
NSW, 2351, Australia. Telephone (087) 7333. Fax (067) 73 3122. E-mail: relliot@metz.une.oz.au
Wouter Achterberg is the contact person for the United Kingdom and Europe
(For Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union, see below.) Those in Western
Europe and the Mediterranean should send their dues to him (the equivalent
of $ 10 US) at the Faculty of Philosophy, University of Amsterdam, Nieuwe
Doelenstraat 15, 1012 CP Amsterdam, Netherlands. Contact him if in doubt
what currencies he can accept. Fax: 31 (country code) 20 (city code) 5254503.
Phone: 31-20-5254530.
Jan Wawrzyniak is the contact person for Eastern Europe and the former Soviet
Union. He is on the faculty in the Department of Philosophy at Adam Mickiewicz
University of Poznan, Poland. Because of the fluid economic situation in
Eastern Europe, members and others should contact him regarding the amount
of dues and the method of payment. He also requests that persons in Eastern
Europe send him information relevant to a regional newsletter attachment
to this newsletter, as well as to share such information with the international
membership of the society. Business address: Institut Filozofii, Adam Mickiewicz
University, 60-569 Poznan, Szamarzewskiego 91c, Poland. Phone: 48 (country
code) 61 (city code) 46461, ext. 288, 280. Fax: 48 (country code) 61 (city
code) 535535 (NOTE NEW FAX). He reports that mail service is very unreliable
in certain parts of Eastern Europe. Home address: 60-592 Poznan, Szafirowa
7, Poland. Phone 48/61/417275. Checks can be sent to his home with more
security.
Azizan Baharuddin, Faculty of Science, University of Malaya, is the contact
person for ISEE for South-East Asia (Burma, Thailand, Malaysia, Singapore,
Vietnam, Laos, Cambodia, Indonesia, and the Philippines). Dr. Azizan teaches
history and philosophy in the Science Faculty. Contact her with regard to
membership and dues payable (the approximate equivalent of $US 10, but with
appropriate adjustment for currency differentials and purchasing power).
Her address is The Dean's Office, Faculty of Science, University of Malaya,
59100 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Fax 60 (Country code) 3 (City code) 756-6343.
Members and others are encouraged to submit appropriate items for the newsletter
to Holmes Rolston, Department of Philosophy, Colorado State University,
Fort Collins, CO 80523, who is editing this newsletter. Phone 303/491-5328
(office) or 491-6315 (philosophy office) or 484-5883 (home). Fax: 303-491-4900,
24 hours. News may also be submitted to Laura Westra, Department of Philosophy,
University of Windsor, Ontario, Canada N9B 3P4, and Canadian news is best
directed to her. Items may also be submitted to other members of the Governing
Board. Include the name of an appropriate contact person, where relevant
and possible. International items are especially welcomed. The Newsletter
is assembled shortly after January 1, April 1, July 1, October 1.
ISEE dues for 1993 are payable now. Memberships run on a calendar year basis,
with NEW members who join in October, November, and December having memberships
extended through the following full calendar year. The Secretary is not
ordinarily able to send receipts, as this takes additional time and expense.
The Society runs on a rather minimal budget, with dues mostly (and barely)
covering the costs of Newsletter printing and mailing. To pay dues, see
the last page of the Newsletter.
Back issues of the ISEE Newsletter? Back issues are available at US $ 10.00
per year, or $ 4.00 per single issue, and these requests should be directed
to the Secretary (address on last page).
The ISEE Newsletter is printed on recycled paper.
Videotapes and media
--WHEN THE BOUGH BREAKS: OUR CHILDREN, OUR ENVIRONMENT. 52 minutes. This
video illustrates how children's lives are the first to suffer in environmental
degradation. There are segments in Poland, in Delhi, in Sudan and Eritrea,
in Bolivia, in the U.S., Europe, and Japan. Each time there are families
affected by decisions that spend money on other things (war, repaying national
debts, or overconsumption elsewhere) and leave children suffering in a degraded
environment. Available through Bullfrog Films, Oley, PA 19547. Phone 215/779-8226.
KEEPERS OF THE EARTH: NATIVE AMERICAN STORIES. Audiotape, 25 native American
legends, exploring the human relation with the natural environment. 133
minutes. $ 16.95. Signals, P. O. Box 64428, St. Paul, MN 55164-0428. 800/669-9696.
Recent Books, Articles, and Other Materials
--UNESCO, WORLD DIRECTORY OF ACADEMIC RESEARCH GROUPS IN SCIENCE ETHICS.
Science Policy Studies and Documents, No. 73. Paris: UNESCO, 1993. 168 pages.
Listings and details of 250 such groups throughout the world, including
(no. 233) the International Society for Environmental Ethics. United Nations
Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization, 7, place de Fontenoy,
75700 Paris, France. With an index of researchers as well as of research
groups. Also lists publications of these groups.
--Joseph A. Miller, Sarah M. Friedman, David C. Grigsby, and Annette Huddle,
compilers, THE ISLAND PRESS BIBLIOGRAPHY OF ENVIRONMENTAL LITERATURE. Washington,
DC: Island Press, 1993. 396 pages. Hardbound, $ 48. 3,084 entries, includes
a section on "Ethics, Philosophy, and Religion." The authors are
with the Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies.
--Hisatake Katoh, KANKYO-RINRIGAKU NO SUSUME (RECOMMENDATION FOR ENVIRONMENTAL
ETHICS). Tokyo: Maruzen Library, 1991. 227 pages. paper. ISBN 4-621-05032-X
C0212. The first book in Japanese in environmental ethics. The book is divided
into three parts: The chapter topics are: 1. The Basic Three Points of Environmental
Ethics. 2. Nature and Human Beings. 3. Future Generations. 4. Globalism.
5. The Role of Japan. 6. Population and Environment. 7. Bioethics and Environmental
Ethics. 8. Garbage and Nature. 9. Generations and Historical Relativism.
10. Rights of Future Generations. 11. How Far Can We Extend Rights? 12.
Conservation and Land Ethics in the United States. 13. Ecology and Economics.
14. Reconsidering Naturalism. Hisatake Katoh is professor of ethics at Chiba
University, and is in the Department of Literature there. The city of Chiba
is in Chiba prefecture, near Tokyo.
--Ethical Institute of Chiva University, STUDY OF BIOETHICS AND ENVIRONMENTAL
ETHICS (in Japanese). Chiva, Japan: Ethical Institute of Chiva University,
1990. The chapters are: Masua, Introduction to Callicott's Ideas; Nagakura,
Introduction to Callicott's Ideas; Osawa, Introduction to Chiras' Ideas;
Nitta, Introduction to Rolston's Ideas; Unoki, Introduction to Shrader-
Frechette's and Feinberg's Ideas; Tanimoto, Introduction to Shrader-Frechette's
Ideas; Ishikawa, Introduction to Glover's Ideas; Matsukawa, Introduction
to McIntyre's Ideas; and Maruyama, Introduction to Shrader-Frechette and
Others.
--Shigeyuki Okajima, AMERICANO KANNKYO HOGO UNNDOU (THE UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL
MOVEMENT. Tokyo: Iwanami Shinsho, 1990. 212 + 21 pages. paper. ISBN 4-00-430142-4
C0229 P580E. Chapters open with Earth Day and the spotted owl controversy,
then survey the origins of environmentalism in the U.S. Emerson, Thoreau,
Muir. Muir and the Sierra Club. Hetch Hetchy. The growth of environmentalism
as a citizen's movement. An increasing maturing and professionalism of environmental
organizations. David Brower. Leopold and the growth of the wilderness movement.
Robert Marshall, William Douglas. The Wilderness Act. The development of
ecology. Rachel Carson. From nature conservation to environmental protection.
Frazer Darling, Stephen Mather. Increasing global problems. Alaska issues.
Is environmentalism an elite movement? International issues. Debt for nature
swaps. Lovejoy. Jessica Mathews. The growth of the environmental education
movement. Shigeyuki Okajima is a journalist with THE YOMIURI SHIMBUN, a
Tokyo newspaper, who has recently been an Eisenhower Fellow in the United
States. See notes above in the General Announcements Section.
--Peter Matthiessen, "The Last Cranes of Siberia," NEW YORKER,
May 3, 1993. The cranes of Russia are facing extinction amid Russia's economic
anarchy, as multinational corporations and local entrepreneurs plunder the
natural resources of Siberia's Amur Basin. Now environmental delegates from
Russia, China, Japan, and the U.S. are putting aside national disputes in
the fight to save the region's endangered species.
--Gary G. Gray, WILDLIFE AND PEOPLE: THE HUMAN DIMENSION OF WILDLIFE ECOLOGY.
Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press, 1993. 260 pages. $ 39.95.
--Ronald Bailey, ECO-SCAM: THE FALSE PROPHETS OF ECOLOGICAL APOCALYPSE.
St. Martin's. 228 pages. $ 19.95. Bailey skewers false prophets and their
failed forecasts. Paul Ehrlich won a MacArthur Foundation "genius"
grant and the Swedish Academy's Crafoord price. He also predicted in 1969
that hundreds of millions would soon perish in smog disasters in New York
and Los Angeles, that the oceans would die of DDT poisoning by 1979, and
that the U. S. life expectancy would drop to 42 years by 1980 due to cancer
epidemics. Lester Brown, another MacArthur genius and Worldwatch Institute
president, predicted that global oil production would peak in 1990. Carl
Sagan predicted that the Kuwaiti oil fires would lead to a global freeze.
The global warming issue, "the mother of all environmental scares"
is a another eco-scam. All the risks associated with the ozone layer do
not amount to moving more than 100 miles south, from Washington, DC to Richmond,
Virginia. Only fifteen years ago, Stephen Schneider, now fearing global
warming, was then fearing global cooling. Nor does it make any difference
what the eco- catastrophe faced is, the problem is always industrial capitalism.
Bailey was formerly a writer with FORBES and is now a producer for the PBS
series, "Technopolitics."
--Michael Fumento, SCIENCE UNDER SIEGE: BALANCING TECHNOLOGY AND THE ENVIRONMENT.
Morrow. 448 pages. $ 27. Fumento debunks such popular cancer threats as
Alar, dioxin, pesticides, electromagnetic fields, and food irradiation.
Extracting human risks from lab tests on chemical-stuffed rats is absurd,
especially absurd when used to project "zero-risk" environments.
The American public is constantly warned of the dangers from tobacco, alcohol,
and poor diet, and these dwarf any risks from chemical residues. Fumento
is a lawyer-journalist who writes on environmental topics for INVESTOR'S
BUSINESS DAILY.
--Micah Morrison, FIRE IN PARADISE: THE YELLOWSTONE FIRES AND THE POLITICS
OF ENVIRONMENTALISM. New York: HarperCollins, 1993. The ecosystem paradigm
has become a quasi-mystical idea, shifting out of the realm of rigorous
scientific inquiry and into our culture without serious challenge, promoted
by environmentalists as a religion. In 1988, Yellowstone paid the price
for ecosystem management as fires played out their "naturally regulating"
role in the ecosystem. The blazes eventually covered 1.2 million acres,
cost the taxpayer $ 120 million, and led to three deaths. We must begin
redefining the ecosystem paradigm, arguing for mankind's [sic] proper role
as a wise steward of the land, not as an enemy of its "natural functions."
And part of wise stewardship means sometimes protecting the forest from
its natural enemy, fire. Wise use also means ruling in favor of jobs over
spotted owls in the Pacific Northwest, and in favor of middle-class development
over gnatcatching birds in Southern California. Morrison finds Alston Chase
a role model. Morrison is senior editor of INSIGHT magazine.
--Alexander Wilson, THE CULTURE OF NATURE: NORTH AMERICAN LANDSCAPE FROM
DISNEY TO THE EXXON VALDEZ. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell, 1992. 335 pages. Human
influences on the North American landscape.
--Andrew Brennan, ed., THE ETHICS OF THE ENVIRONMENT, in THE INTERNATIONAL
RESEARCH LIBRARY OF PHILOSOPHY. 500 pages. Hardcover. $ 134.95. Aldershot,
Hampshire, U.K.: Dartmouth Publishing Co., forthcoming, spring 1994. U.S.
Distributor: Ashgate Publishing Co., Old Post Road, Brookfield, VT 05036.
Brennan is professor of philosophy, University of Western Australia. More
on this in due course.
--Harold H. Oliver, "The Neglect and Recovery of Nature in Twentieth-Century
Protestant Thought," JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY OF RELIGION 60
(no. 3, 1992):379-404. Protestants neglected a long heritage of theology
of nature and, in the first part of the twentieth century "`nature'
became the ward of science and technology, with little interference--and
less wisdom--from the Church." The Protestant theological giants, Barth,
Brunner, and Bultmann, willfully rejected a theology of nature, though Tillich
sought to be more inclusive. The theologians overvalued world history and
devalued nature. The ecological crisis has had an awakening effect, especially
when blame for the ecological crisis was laid at the door of Christianity
itself. More recent proposals for an integral theology have the criteria
of wholeness, mutuality, responsivity, and mystery. Oliver is professor
of philosophical theology at Boston University School of Theology.
--Mark Sagoff, "Settling America or the Concept of Place in Environmental
Ethics," JOURNAL OF ENERGY, NATURAL RESOURCES, AND ENVIRONMENTAL LAW
(University of Utah College of Law): 12 (no. 2, 1992):349-418. Some section
titles: America on the Move; Place and Placelessness; Nature is Not a Place;
The Environment is Not a Place; Protectionism; The Country vs. the City;
Down on the Farm; Place as Res Publica; The Chesapeake; the North Sea; Have
We a Place in Nature?; Nature as Human Habitat; The Great Environmental
Awakening; Geography and History; Sustainability and Community; Environmentalism
and the Dominant Social Paradigm. Sagoff is Director of the Institute for
Philosophy and Public Policy, University of Maryland. Copies are available
on request: School of Public Affairs, College Park, MD 20742. Phone 301/405-
4753. Fax: 301/314-9346.
--Raymond Bonner, AT THE HAND OF MAN: PERIL AND HOPE FOR AFRICA'S WILDLIFE.
New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1993. 322 pages. $ 24.00. Bonner thinks there
has been much folly in Western led efforts at wildlife conservation in Africa.
He is especially critical of the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) or World Wide
Fund for Nature and the Africa Wildlife Fund. He thinks that these funds
have used the ban on the ivory trade, for instance, to increase membership
and donations, while a controlled sale of ivory would have been more effective
at saving elephants. These funds have been too interested in the animals,
and not interested enough in the Africa peoples, whose fortunes are tied
to those of the animals. Bonner is a former NEW YORK TIMES correspondent.
--Edwin Philip Pister, "Species in a Bucket, NATURAL HISTORY, January
1993. Phil Pister's celebrated story of an emergency transfer of the Owens
pupfish (CYPRINODON RADIOSUS), an endangered species in California, from
one spring to another, when he held the entire population of the species
in two buckets. "For a few frightening moments, there was only myself
standing between life and extinction." Pister is a retired fisheries
biologist with the Desert Fishes Council, Bishop, California.
--Stephen Jay Gould, "A Special Fondness for Beetles," NATURAL
HISTORY, January 1993. J. B. S. Haldane's quip that God has an inordinate
fondness for beetles leads Gould to examine the estimates for the numbers
of beetles in the world. A conclusion: "Our world is incredibly strange
and therefore supremely fascinating." Gould is a paleontologist at
Harvard University.
--SCIENCE, June 25, 1993, is a special issue devoted to "Environment
and the Economy." A lead editorial complains of the "pathological
growth of [environmental] regulations." Carl Sagan and Edward O. Wilson
protest against having (allegedly) been "blacklisted" by SCIENCE
because their advocacy prejudices their scientific credibility. Articles:
"Protecting the Environment with the Power of the Market," "Is
Environmental Technology a Key to a Healthy Economy?" "Can Sustainable
Farming Win the Battle of the Bottom Line? Few Options for Third World Farmers,"
"How to Make the Forests of the World Pay Their Own Way," and
"Wetlands Trading is a Loser's Game Say Ecologists: Bringing Vanished
Wetlands to Life," (i.e. mitigation doesn't work).
--Herman E. Daly and Kenneth N. Townsend, eds., VALUING THE EARTH: ECONOMICS,
ECOLOGY, ETHICS. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1993. 14 contributors. This is
a successor to the 1973 TOWARD A STEADY STATE ECONOMY and the 1980 ECONOMICS,
ECOLOGY, ETHICS: ESSAYS TOWARD A STEADY STATE ECONOMY. A sample of the new
essays: Daly: "Sustainable Growth: An Impossibility Theorem."
Daly is an economist with the World Bank; Townsend is professor of economics
at Hampden Sydney College.
--Nazli Choucri, ed., GLOBAL ACCORD: ENVIRONMENTAL CHALLENGES AND INTERNATIONAL
RESPONSES. Cambridge: MIT Press. 688 pages. $ 45.00. Fifteen essays on how
individuals, groups, and nations create environmental dislocations and can
work together to solve ecological problems that cross their borders. Choucri
is professor of political science at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
--Peter M. Haas, Robert O. Keohane, and Marc A. Levy, eds., INSTITUTIONS
FOR THE EARTH: SOURCES OF EFFECTIVE INTERNATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 1993. 340 pages. $ 17.95 paper. Seven international
problems: oil pollution from tankers, acid rain in Europe, pollution of
the North Sea and Baltic, stratospheric ozone depletion, mismanagement of
fisheries, overpopulation, and misuses of farm chemicals. Analyses such
institutions as the United Nations Environment Programme, the Intergovernmental
Maritime Organization, the Food and Agriculture Organization, the United
Nations Fund for Population Assistance, and others. The authors are political
scientists at the University of Massachusetts, Harvard University, and Princeton
University.
--Kent H. Redford and Christine Padoch, eds., CONSERVATION OF NEOTROPICAL
FORESTS: WORKING FROM TRADITIONAL RESOURCE USE. New York: Columbia University
Press, 1992. 475 pages. Redford is in he Department of Wildlife and Range
Science at the University of Florida. Padoch is at the New York Botanical
Garden.
--Robert Rosen, LIFE ITSELF: A COMPREHENSIVE INQUIRY INTO THE NATURE, ORIGIN,
AND FABRICATION OF LIFE. New York: Columbia University Press, 1991. 285
pages. Rosen argues that life modeled as mechanism is neither necessary
nor sufficient for understanding what life is, despite three centuries of
such presumption in science. What is life? "The initial presupposition
that we are dealing with mechanism already excludes most of what we need
to arrive at an answer." Drawing from biology, physics, and mathematics,
he proposes an alternative radically different from mechanism. With lots
of mathematics. Rosen is professor of physiology and biophysics, Faculty
of Medicine, Dalhousie University.
--Timothy F. H. Allen and Thomas W. Hoekstra, TOWARD A UNIFIED ECOLOGY.
New York: Columbia University Press, 1992. An attempt to bring basic ecology
to bear on ecological management, with particular attention to differences
of scale. Allen is professor botany, University of Wisconsin, Madison. Hoekstra
is at the Rocky Mountain Forest and Range Experiment Station, Fort Collins,
Colorado.
--Thomas K. Rudel with Bruce Horowitz, TROPICAL DEFORESTATION: SMALL FARMERS
AND LAND CLEARING IN THE ECUADORIAN AMAZON. New York: Columbia University
Press, 1993. 234 pages. Rudel teaches sociology and human ecology at Rutgers
University. Horowitz is a lawyer and professor at Universidad San Francisco
de Quito, Ecuador.
--Daniel S. Smith and Paul Cawood Hellmund, eds., ECOLOGY OF GREENWAYS:
DESIGN AND FUNCTION OF LINEAR CONSERVATION AREAS. 308 pages. hardbound,
$ 39.95. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1993. Greenways are
naturally vegetated corridors to maintain biological diversity on otherwise
fragmented landscape ecosystems, as well as to provide recreational and
other benefits.
--Will Wright, WILD KNOWLEDGE: SCIENCE, LANGUAGE, AND SOCIAL LIFE IN A FRAGILE
ENVIRONMENT. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1992. 240 pages.
Paper, $ 14.95. "Scientific knowledge ... is primarily an effort at
social legitimization and ... its conceptual incoherence as knowledge is
now becoming ecological incoherence as social practice." Wright wants
to invent a new idea of science by replacing its traditional concept of
laws, especially mathematical laws, with a social concept of language. Wright
is professor of sociology at the University of Southern Colorado.
--Dwight Baldwin, Jr., Judith de Luce, and Carl Pletsch, eds., BEYOND PRESERVATION:
RESTORING AND INVENTING LANDSCAPES. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota
Press, 1993. The theory of preservation is predicated on the assumption
that as humans we are different from and opposed to the rest of nature,
but the contributors here explore the belief that humans are inextricably
entangled with nature and therefore have an unavoidable impact upon the
entire ecosystem. The contributors explore the possibilities of restoring
damaged landscapes and even of inventing new ones. The editors are landscape
architects at the University of Miami, Ohio.
--Jane Bennett and William Chaloupka, eds., IN THE NATURE OF THINGS: LANGUAGE,
POLITICS, AND THE ENVIRONMENT. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press,
1993. 224 pages. $ 17.95, paper. Informed by recent developments in literary
criticism and social theory, the contributors address the presumption that
nature exists independently of culture and, in particular, of language.
The theoretical approaches of the contributors range across both modernist
and postmodernist positions, including feminist theory, critical theory,
Marxism, science-fiction, theology, and botany. The concept of nature is
invoked and constituted in a wide range of cultural projects--from the Bible
to science fiction movies, from hunting to green consumerism. How far is
nature a social construct?
--Michael Carley and Ian Christie, MANAGING SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT. Minneapolis:
University of Minnesota Press, 1993. Co-published with Earthscan in the
United Kingdom. 288 pages. Paper, $ 19.95. Sustainable development is an
intensely political process, however defined and on whatever scale, and
involves continual trade-offs between economic, social, and biophysical
needs and objectives. The authors propose an action-centered network as
a key innovation in environmental management.
--ON THE OTHER HAND: NEWS FROM THE RUSSIAN ENVIRONMENT has published volume
1, no. 3, May 1993. The current issue includes: Irene Khalyi, "The
Environmental Movement in Russia: Contemporary Trends"; Yu S. Kamalov,
"The Rights of the Aral Sea"; A. Tulokhonov, "Sustainable
Development for Baikal." The U. S. editor is Ernest Partridge, Northland
College, Wisconsin; the Russian editor is Anton Struchkov, Academy of Sciences,
Moscow.
--Kathleen Norris, DAKOTA: A SPIRITUAL GEOGRAPHY. Ticknor and Fields, 224
pages. $ 19.95. Norris is from Lemmon, South Dakota, 1,600 people, the largest
town in an area twice the size of Massachusetts. Though reared first in
New York, she has lived there twenty years, and knows both worlds. She finds
the great plains a world where things are timeless and deep, offering gifts
of grace and revelation, despite the usual perception that the Dakotas are
stuck in an earlier, less relevant age. The plains are a sanctuary. Norris
is a lay preacher in the Presbyterian Church, also an associate in a community
of Benedictine monks, as well as an environmentalist and citizen. A very
sensitive book, with a marvelous sense of place.
--W. M. Adams, WASTING THE RAIN: RIVERS, PEOPLE, AND PLANNING IN AFRICA.
Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1993. Co- published with Earthscan
in the United Kingdom. 240 pages. $ 17.95, paper. For much of Africa, drought
seems to be a permanent feature. Many attempts have been made to develop
water resources through dams and irrigation schemes, but these have almost
invariably failed. The best hope of appropriate development lies in working
with local people using local knowledge. Adams wants to use the strength
and diversity of indigenous water development in the difficult and often
variable climate of Africa. The record of the modern, large-scale developments,
particularly dams and irrigation schemes, has been poor and ineffective
in conservation.
--William Cronon, NATURE'S METROPOLIS: CHICAGO AND THE GREAT WEST. Norton,
1991. "But the labor theory of value cannot by itself explain the astonishing
accumulation of capital that accompanied Chicago's growth. Human labor may
have been critical ... but much of the value in such commodities came directly
from the first, not second, nature. The fertility of the prairie soils and
the abundance of the northern forests had far less to do with human labor
than with autonomous ecological processes. ... The abundance that fueled
Chicago's hinterland economy thus consisted largely of stored sunshine:
this was the wealth of nature, and no human labor could create the value
it contained ... "The social relations of production ... themselves
depended on still more encompassing ecological relations on CONSUMPTION.
In any ecosystem, only the sun produces. ... Since no organism can make
energy, each must do its best to STORE it, accumulating a stockpile for
use when the sun will not be so generous with its gifts. The same is true
of human society: most of the labor that goes into `PRODUCING' grain, lumber,
and meat involves CONSUMING part of the natural world and setting aside
some portion of the resulting wealth as `capital.' To apply for a moment
the language of economy to the ecology of the Great West, Chicago's explosive
growth was purchased at the expense of prairies and forests that had spent
centuries accumulating the wealth that now made `free land' so attractive.
Much of the capital that made the city was nature's own" (pp. 149-151).
(Thanks to Bruce Omundson.)
--Robert Goodland and Herman Daly, "Poverty Alleviation Is Essential
for Environmental Sustainability," The World Bank Environmental Department,
Divisional Working Paper 1993-42. More than one-fifth of humanity lives
in poverty; nearly two-thirds of humanity subsist on less than $ 2 per day.
The numbers of poor are increasing. The world is hurtling away from environmental
sustainability. Five views are contrasted on how to alleviate poverty: the
trickle-down theory, that the North must consume more to expand markets
for Southern raw materials. The elitist choice, that the rich foster poverty
because it creates low wage labor. Capital seeks cheap labor. Anthropocentric,
people-centered environmentalism, places humans at the center of the cosmos,
the rest is derivative. The biocentric view claims that the living ecosystem
is central; humans are part of it. We have a duty to conserve the whole.
Redistributive justice asserts that poverty can be alleviated directly by
improving access of the poor to shelter, clothing, food, education, and
security. The authors are with the World Bank. Copies from World Bank, Environment
Department, Washington, DC 20433. Fax 202/477-0565.
--Robert Goodland, "Ethical Priorities in Environmentally Sustainable
Energy Systems: The Case of Tropical Hydropower," a paper given at
a conference in Montreal, Quebec, in May, "Energy Needs in the Year
2000 and Beyond: Ethical and Environmental Perspectives." Includes
six ethical-environmental criteria. Two of them: "Environmental impact
is roughly proportional to area inundated. Therefore, the proposed dam must
have the highest feasible ratio of power production per area inundated.
If not, then the project has a higher than necessary environmental impact,
which could be unethical." "The proposed site and surroundings
have no centers of species endemism, rich biodiversity or other special
features. If not, the ethics of extinction of species have been disregarded."
Copies from address in previous entry.
--Alan E. Wittbecker, "An Ecological Development Plan for the Palouse
Region," PAN ECOLOGY 8, no. 1, Winter 1993. An approach to mixing nature
and culture in this dry, intermountain grassland in the Columbia Basin of
the U. S. Pacific Northwest.
--David Ehrenfeld, BEGINNING AGAIN: PEOPLE AND NATURE IN THE NEW MILLENNIUM.
New York: Oxford University Press, 1993. 216 pages. Hardcover. $ 22.00.
A collection of essays. "Human population, powered by an unforgiving,
ill-adapted, and poorly functioning technology, is rapidly growing past
the inevitable crash point." Gary Nabhan says, "Not since SAND
COUNTY ALMANAC has an ecologist given us so many enduring insights and principles
to inspire and guide our lives on this planet." Ehrenfeld is in natural
resources at Rutgers University.
--John P. O'Grady, PILGRIMS TO THE WILD: EVERETT RUESS, HENRY DAVID THOREAU,
JOHN MUIR, CLARENCE KING, MARY AUSTIN. Logan: University of Utah Press,
1993. Paper. $ 16.95. "A series of meditations focused upon literary
excursions into `the wild' ... The fundamental assumption I employ--call
it a perception--is that the wild is erotic space, and the pilgrimages I
am concerned with are journeys through that space." O'Grady is professor
in a wilderness literature program at the University of California, Davis.
--Vernon W. Ruttan, ed., AGRICULTURE, ENVIRONMENT, AND HEALTH: TOWARD SUSTAINABLE
DEVELOPMENT IN THE 21ST CENTURY. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press,
1993. 384 pages. Paper, $ 19.95. The changes in institutional design and
policy reforms now underway will ultimately provide sustainable growth in
agricultural production. Especially important are the institutions that
conduct research and implement advances in technology and practice in the
fields of agriculture and health, as well as those that monitor the changes
in resource endowments, the quality of the environment and of health, and
the productivity of humans employed in agricultural production. Rattan is
in agricultural economics at the University of Minnesota.
--Rogene A. Bucholtz, "Corporate Responsibility and the Good Society:
From Economics to Ecology," BUSINESS HORIZONS (Indiana University Graduate
School of Business) 34, no. 4 (1991):19-31. The economic paradigm will continue
its dominance as long as human beings consider themselves to be the center
of life on earth.
--James A. Post, "Managing As If the Earth Mattered," BUSINESS
HORIZONS 34, no. 4 (1991): 32-38. Managers can no longer ignore environmental
problems; they must manage as if the earth mattered, because in fact it
does.
--BUSINESS HORIZONS, "Business and the Environment," a special
issue, vol. 35, no. 2, March-April 1992. About a dozen articles on a deepening
commitment in business to environmental integrity. Samples: Richard E. Byrd,
"Corporate Integrity: Paradise Lost and Regained." The corporate
hell of lack of integrity is not permanent, but getting out takes real commitment.
Frank B. Friedman, "The Changing Role of the Environmental Manager."
Managers must think "environment" today more than ever; knowledge
and awareness are the keys. William K. Reilly, "Environment, Inc."
Cooperation between U.S. corporations and the government on the environmental
front forms a model for the world. (Thanks to Wayne Ouderkirk for the above
three references.)
--J. M. Cherett, "Key Concepts: The Results to a Survey of Our Members
Opinions," in J. M. Cherett, ed, ECOLOGICAL CONCEPTS (London: Blackwells,
1989), pages 1-16. The fifty most important concepts in ecology, as revealed
in a survey of the British Ecological Society.
--EARTHWORK is a magazine for people pursuing careers in conservation and
environmental affairs. Job listings and advice on launching a conservation
career. Published by the Student Conservation Association, Inc., dedicated
to fostering conservation careers since 1957. Contact EARTHWORK, P. O. Box
550, Charlestown, NH 03603. Phone 603/543-1700.
--Holmes Rolston, III, "Whose Woods These Are. Are Genetic Resources
Private Property or Global Commons? EARTHWATCH, vol. 12, no. 3 (March/April
1993):17-18. Ownership of wild species, sometimes being claimed by Third
World Nations, makes national resources out of a natural resource that has
classically been part of the common heritage of humankind. There are conceptual
and practical problems with claiming such wild species ownership. These
species belong to us all, with a shared right to use and responsibility
to protect.
--CHOOSING A SUSTAINABLE FUTURE: THE REPORT OF THE NATIONAL COMMISSION ON
THE ENVIRONMENT. Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993. The report of a private
sector initiative convened by the World Wildlife Fund. Nineteen prominent
members. "We the members of the National Commission on the Environment,
are convinced that the natural processes that support life on Earth are
increasingly at risk and that by choosing to act or not to act to confront
this risk now, our country is choosing between two very different futures"
(p. xi). Russell E. Train, Chair, World Wildlife Fund and former Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) Administrator and Council on Environmental Quality
Chair (CEQ) was the chair of the commission.
--Anne Buttimer, GEOGRAPHY AND THE HUMAN SPIRIT. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins
University Press, 1993. Geography with a philosophical turn, and with a
postmodernist awareness. Some chapter titles: "The Drama of Western
Humanism," and four world- views in Western geography: "World
as a Mosaic of Forms," "World as Mechanical System," "World
as Organic Whole," "World as Arena of Events." The author
ranges widely, from Plato to Kant to the UPANISHADS, from Goethe to Barry
Lopez. Her book is a "step toward discovering mutually acceptable bases
for rational discourse on wiser ways of dwelling." Buttimer is professor
of geography, University College, Dublin.
--Duane Quiatt and Junichiro Itani, eds., HOMINID CULTURE IN PRIMATE PERSPECTIVE.
Niwot, CO: University Press of Colorado, 1993. 320 pages. $ 32.50. Human
culture and animal behavior are commonly thought to differ importantly through
the use of tools, inventing symbols, making words, and so on. But these
primatologists think that their research indicates that the differences
between human culture and primate behavior are increasingly difficult to
identify. Quiatt is professor of anthropology at the University of Colorado
at Denver; Itani is with the Laboratory of Human Evolution at Kyoto University.
--Karl Hess, Jr., ROCKY TIMES IN ROCKY MOUNTAIN NATIONAL PARK: AN UNNATURAL
HISTORY. Niwot, CO: University Press of Colorado, 1993. 240 pages. $ 22.50.
Hess argues for drastic changes in how the sixth most visited park in the
United States should be managed. Hess thinks the Park Service has faltered
in its mission of preservation, due in part to "predatory politics"
in the Park Service. Hess is described (by his friend Tom Wolf) as "a
kinder, gentler Alston Chase." He is an ecologist and environmental
consultant based in Las Cruces, New Mexico.
--Harold Herzog, "Human Morality and Animal Research," AMERICAN
SCHOLAR, Summer 1993. "When asked where I stand on the animal- research
issue, I have taken to responding with .... `the troubled-middle.' Granted,
the troubled middle is not a comfortable place to be. But, for most of us,
neither are the alternatives." Herzog is professor of psychology at
Western Carolina University.
--Frederick FerrÇ, HELLFIRE AND LIGHTNING RODS: LIBERATING SCIENCE,
TECHNOLOGY AND RELIGION. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books, 1993. Cloth, $ 24.95.
Prevailing models of nature are inadequate because they are too narrow in
their portrayal of a single but polyvalent organic world. The world must
be envisioned organically or be destroyed by stunted and sterile approaches.
FerrÇ is Research Professor of Philosophy at the University of Georgia,
and instrumental in the environmental studies faculty there.
--The Center for Ideas and Society, University of California, Riverside,
offers the following papers:
---"The Role of Technology in Environmental Questions: Martin Buber
and Deep Ecology as Answers to Technological Consciousness"
---"Rereading Bookchin and Marcuse as Environmental Materialists,"
with reply by Bookchin and various commentaries
---"Materialists, Ontologists, and Environmental Pragmatists"
---"Environmental Pragmatism and Valuation in Nature"
---"Environmental Neo-Pragmatism"
---"Rationality, Nature, and Folk Technology" Contact Andrew Light,
Center for Ideas and Society, University of California, Riverside, CA 92521.
Phone 909/686-5045. Fax 714/787-6377.
--Christopher D. Stone, THE GNAT IS OLDER THAN MAN: GLOBAL ENVIRONMENT AND
HUMAN AGENDA. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1993. 341 pp. $ 21.95.
Proposes a Global Commons Trust Fund, monies raised on the premise that
nations using the common heritage of the planet--the oceans, the atmosphere--be
charged for their use. The natural environment and species within it can,
from this fund, be represented by "ecoguardians." Stone is a law
professor at the University of Southern California Law School.
--Donald Worster, THE WEALTH OF NATURE: ENVIRONMENTAL HISTORY AND THE ECOLOGICAL
IMAGINATION. New York: Oxford University Press, 1993. 255 pp. $ 25.00. A
collection of essays. Past ideas about the relations of humans to nature
persist unavailingly into the present. No amount of tinkering will correct
what, at root, is a fundamentally obsolete and dangerous world view dependent
on the appropriation of nature. Worster wants "to discover a less-
reductive, less-ecologically and spiritually nihilistic, less- grasping
kind of materialism." With a tinge of fatalism. Worster is a historian
at the University of Kansas, Lawrence.
--C. A. Bowers, EDUCATION, CULTURAL MYTHS, AND THE ECOLOGICAL CRISIS: TOWARD
DEEP CHANGES. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press, 1993. 232
pates. $ 12.95 paper. "The cultural dimensions of the ecological crisis
raise profound questions for educators who play such a key role in passing
on the cultural templates to the next generation." Most teaching in
U.S. schools and universities, whether liberal or conservative, promotes
attitudes that lead to overconsumption and pollution. Most reform advocates
do not see how there must be a "radical reform of the educational process."
Bowers teaches at Portland State University and at the University of Oregon.
--John A. Jakle and David Wilson, DERELICT LANDSCAPES: THE WASTING OF AMERICA'S
BUILT ENVIRONMENT. Savage, MD: Rowman and Littlefield, 1992. 342 pp. Paper,
$ 22.95. Recent landscape change in America through the lens of dereliction.
Americans "accept whole categories of decline as somehow natural, when
decline is in fact a societal construction" (p. xvii). Chronic dereliction
reveals a basic flaw in American values. With a sense of alarm for the state
of the built environment.
--C. C. W. (Christopher Charles Whiston) Taylor, ETHICS AND THE ENVIRONMENT.
Oxford, UK: Corpus Christi College, 1992. 97 pp., paper. Proceedings of
a conference held at Corpus Christi College, Oxford, September 20-21, 1991.
--Craig Moritz, Jiro Kikkawa, and David Dooley, eds., CONSERVATION BIOLOGY
IN AUSTRALIA AND OCEANIA. 500 pages, hardbound, $ 74.95. 1993. In Australia:
Surrey Beatty and Sons. In the U.S. distributed by: University of Minnesota
Press.
--John Harte, THE GREEN FUSE: AN ECOLOGIST'S ODYSSEY. Berkeley, University
of California Press, 1993. 156 pages. Hardbound, $ 15.00. An ecologist and
activist draws on his research as well as on literature to demonstrate the
intricate connections among disparate ecosystems. A bridge between the cultures
of science and art. "The green fuse" symbolizes the basic unity
behind natural diversity. Hart is professor of energy and resources at the
University of California, Berkeley.
--Stephen H. Kellert, IN THE WAKE OF CHAOS. Chicago: The University of Chicago
Press, 1993. 176 pages. Hardbound, $ 19.95. We are in the wake of chaos,
trying to make sense of the news that the universe is a far more unpredictable
place than anyone ever imagined. The randomness that was first discovered
in simple systems--a curl of smoke, a tumble of water--has exploded into
a fascination with chaotic modes of everything from evolutionary history,
ecosystem functioning, brain waves, business cycles. How order and turbulence,
long-term predictability and short-term instability balance each other in
the picture of nature. Kellert teaches philosophy of science at Indiana
University.
--Gunnar Hansen, ISLANDS AT THE EDGE OF TIME. Washington, DC: Island Press,
Shearwater Books, 1993. 240 pages. Hardbound, $ 22.50. Barrier islands run
for 2700 miles from Texas to Maine, the longest stretch in the world. They
are small islands, they are ephemeral, moving constantly with the sea's
motion. But despite their fragility, barrier islands are monuments to the
strength and beauty of nature, and to our precarious, yet lasting, ties
to the land. Hansen is an environmental writer who lives in Maine.
--Stephen R. Kellert and Edward O. Wilson, eds., THE BIOPHILIA HYPOTHESIS.
Washington, DC: Island Press, Shearwater Books, 1993. Biophilia is E. O.
Wilson's term for an innate human affinity for the natural world. People
are disposed to like certain kind of environments. Experience with natural
life and the life processes is a biologically based need, integral to our
development as individuals. There is also, perhaps, some biophobia, innate
fear of nature, for example of snakes and spiders. Biological conservation
can, in part at least, be built on these innate, genetic dispositions. We
need to save nature for our own well- being. Sixteen contributors. The philosophical
contribution is by Holmes Rolston, who asks whether Wilson's ideas about
biophilia are compatible with his ideas about selfish genes. Kellert is
in forestry at Yale University, Wilson is a zoologist at Harvard University.
--Robert Gottlieb, FORCING THE SPRING: THE TRANSFORMATION OF THE AMERICAN
ENVIRONMENTAL MOVEMENT. Washington: Island Press, 1993. 413 pages. Hardbound,
$ 27.50. Gottlieb thinks that environmentalism began as the conservation
of wild nature but has been increasingly broadened and transformed to include
industries, cities, agriculture, pollution issues, public health issues.
He wants to shift the debate from one focused exclusively on the protection
and management of the natural world to a wider discussion of American social
development in harmony with nature. Is the environmental movement capable
of transcending its origins and changing the very fabric of American social
life? Gottlieb teaches environmental policy in the Urban Planning Program
at UCLA.
--Rocky Barker, SAVING ALL THE PARTS: RECONCILING ECONOMICS AND THE ENDANGERED
SPECIES ACT. Washington: Island Press, 1993. 260 pages. Hardbound, $ 30.00
The "jobs versus the environment" issues, explored in detail.
Ways in which economic activity can be sustained without the loss of essential
natural values. Barker is a journalist with the Idaho Falls POST REGISTER.
--Sara F. Bates, David H. Getches, Lawrence J. MacDonnell, and Charles F.
Wilkinson, SEARCHING OUT THE HEADWATERS: CHANGE AND REDISCOVERY IN WESTERN
WATER POLICY. Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993. 250 pages. Paper, $ 17.95.
Western water use and the outmoded rules that govern it. Only by understanding
the waters of the West and the people whose lives depend upon then can concerned
citizens comprehend the seriousness of the current situation and help take
steps toward reform. The authors are at the University of Colorado School
of Law.
--Charles A. Flink and Robert M. Searns, with editing by Loring LaB. Schwarz.
GREENWAYS: A GUIDE TO PLANNING, DESIGN, AND DEVELOPMENT. Washington, DC:
Island Press, 1993. 320 pages. $ 45.00, hardbound. Greenways are proving
to be the most innovative way of preserving a wide variety of economic,
ecological, wildlife, and social values.
--Karen-Lee Ryan, TRAILS FOR THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY: PLANNING, DESIGN,
AND MANAGEMENT MANUAL FOR MULTI-USE TRAILS. Washington, DC: Island Press,
1993. $ paper, $ 24.95. 290 pages. Thousands of miles of abandoned railroad
corridors, former canals, and other now unused transportation routes are
being converted to trails that provide a wide range of recreational and
functional uses, including walking, cycling, horseback riding, cross country
skiing, and more, all helping persons to re-establish contacts with the
natural world and with their landscapes. Karen-Lee Ryan is program manager
for the Rails-to-Trails Conservancy.
--Durwood Zaelke, Robert F. Housman, and Paul Orbuch, eds., TRADE AND THE
ENVIRONMENT: LAW, ECONOMICS, POLICY. Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993.
$ 24.95, paper. 270 pages. What the General Agreement on Trade and Tariffs
(GATT) and the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) are doing and
might do to the environment. What issues are involved when one country tries
to influence another's environmental standards? How should international
environmental standards be set? When and how are low environmental standards
a subsidy to labor and to industry, and is this appropriate? The authors
are with the Center for International Environmental Law, Washington, DC.
--Joyce K. Berry and John C. Gordon, eds., ENVIRONMENTAL LEADERSHIP: DEVELOPING
EFFECTIVE SKILLS AND STYLES. Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993. Paper,
$ 19.95. 320 pages. The authors argue for an approach that has been used
at Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies with much success.
What characteristics and contexts of leadership are unique to the conservation
field?
--Elliott A. Norse, GLOBAL MARINE BIOLOGICAL DIVERSITY: A STRATEGY FOR BUILDING
CONSERVATION INTO DECISION MAKING. Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993. 350
pages. $ 27.95. Builds on the work of more than 100 expert contributors.
What is marine biological diversity and how is it important? How is it similar
and different to terrestrial diversity? Life in the sea and ways to save,
study, and use that life sustainably. Norse is chief scientist at the Center
for Marine Conservation, also attached to the University of Washington.
--Jon M. Van Dyke, Durwood Zaelke, and Grant Hewison, eds., FREEDOM FOR
THE SEAS IN THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY: OCEAN GOVERNANCE AND ENVIRONMENTAL
HARMONY. Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993. 430 pages. $ 27.50, paper.
The contributors want to change the prevailing concept of freedom of the
seas to that of freedom for the seas, where the primary goal is the protection
of ecological vitality in ocean systems. Van Dyke is professor of law at
the University of Hawaii, Daelke and Hewison are at the Center for International
Environmental Law in Washington.
--Lawrence J. MacDonnell and Sarah F. Bates, eds., NATURAL RESOURCES POLICY
AND LAW. Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993. 280 pages. $ 19.95, paper.
Ten chapters. The authors dislike the traditional narrow economic valuation
of natural resources and argue that we have now begun to appreciate the
inherent worth of our land, air, and water, a worth entirely unrelated to
economic growth and development. The editors are at the University of Colorado
School of Law.
--Robert Adler and Jessica Landman, THE CLEAN WATER ACT TWENTY YEARS LATER.
Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993. 350 pages. $ 29.95 paper. The Clean
Water Act intended to "restore and maintain the chemical, physical,
and biological integrity of the Nation's waters." A detailed examination
of the health of the nation's waters, which turns out to be a complex and
subtle question to address. With recommendations for reauthorization of
the Act. The authors are attorneys at the National Resources Defense Council,
Washington. --Greg Aplet, Nels Johnson, Jeffrey T. Olsen, and V. Alaric
Sample, DEFINING SUSTAINABLE FORESTRY. Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993.
320 pages. Paper, $ 24.95. The authors are with the Wilderness Society,
the World Resources Institute, and the American Forest's Forest Policy Center.
--Robert E. Ricklefs and Dolph Schluter, eds., SPECIES DIVERSITY IN ECOLOGICAL
COMMUNITIES: HISTORICAL AND GEOGRAPHICAL PERSPECTIVES. Chicago: University
of Chicago, 1993. 454 pages. $ 35.00 paper. New theoretical developments,
analyses, and case studies to explore large scale mechanisms that generate
and maintain diversity. Fifty contributors.
--Gregg Mitman, THE STATE OF NATURE: ECOLOGY, COMMUNITY, AND AMERICAN SOCIAL
THOUGHT, 1900-1950. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1992. 290 pages.
$ 23.50 paper. A study of the connection between liberal social thought
and the concept of harmony in nature in the first half of the century. Social
attitudes and commitments shaped ecological thinking, which in turn sought
to influence social and political thinking. There were steady interactions
between ecology and ecologists and ideas of social community and social
forces. The cooperative view of nature eroded in the 1940's and 1950's due
both to the modern Darwinian synthesis of evolution by natural selection,
as well as through the association of organicism with totalitarian ideologies.
Mitman is in the history of science at the University of Oklahoma.
--George B. Schaller, THE LAST PANDA. Chicago: University of Chicago Press,
1993. 291 pages. $ 24.95 hardbound. About 1,000 pandas survive. A live panda
is worth $ 112,000 on the black market, a pelt is worth $ 10,000. Zoos pay
millions to rent pandas. Schaller tracks the panda in the wild and wonders
if it can survive its popularity. Good intentions go desperately wrong,
and greed and poverty prevent conservation. Panda conservation is often
a sham. Schaller is with World Wildlife Conservational International, New
York.
--Donald R. Griffin, ANIMAL MINDS. Chicago: University of Chicago Press,
1992. 310 pages. $ 24.95 hardbound. Continuing a series of earlier books,
Griffin maintains that animals do think, now with further evidence from
animal behavior, the philosophy of mind, and cognitive science. Griffin
is at the Museum of Comparative Anatomy, Harvard.
--R. J. Berry, "Christianity and the Environment: Escapist Mysticism
or Responsible Stewardship," SCIENCE AND CHRISTIAN BELIEF 3, no. 1
(1991):3-18. Christianity, properly understood, leads to a responsible stewardship
of the environment, not to flagrant abuse or escapist mysticism. It converges
with and provides an undergirding to secular thinking as expressed by the
Brundtland Commission on sustainable development and the Economic Summit
Nations on environmental ethics. But Christianity goes further in urging
an awe for creation. Christians have a positive contribution to make and
ought to be bolder in their witness. Berry is professor of genetics at University
College, London, president of the European Ecological Federation, and past-president
of the British Ecological Society and the Linnean Society.
--Mostafa K. Tolba, SAVING OUR PLANET: CHALLENGES AND HOPES. London and
New York: Chapman and Hall, 1992. 287 pages. $ 20, paper. Also in Spanish
as: SALVEMOS EL PLANETA: PROBLEMAS Y ESPERANZOS. The state of the environment,
human well-being, perceptions and attitudes, challenges and priorities for
actions. Tolba is Director of the United Nations Environment Programme.
--Peggy L. Fiedler and Subodh K. Jain, eds., CONSERVATION BIOLOGY: THE THEORY
AND PRACTICE OF NATURE CONSERVATION, PRESERVATION, AND MANAGEMENT. London
and New York: Chapman and Hall, 1992. 18 essays. A sample: G. Ledyard Stebbins,
"Why Should We Conserve Species and Wildlands?" Fiedler is in
biology at San Francisco State University. Jain is at the University of
California, Davis.
--Daniel R. Brooks and Deborah A. McLennan, PARASCRIPT: PARASITES AND THE
LANGUAGE OF EVOLUTION. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press, 1993.
450 pages. $ 25.00 paper. The relationship between parasite and host is
homologous to that between animal and plant. The many traditional generalizations
about parasite evolution are myths, unsupported by data. "Parasites
are not the degenerate, overspecialized, host-dependent creatures ... envisioned
by the proponents of orthogenesis. They are instead successful, innovative
creatures" (p. 181). "Parasites are still an enigma. But ... they
need no longer carry an evolutionary stigma" (p. 209). The authors
are in the department of zoology at the University of Toronto.
--Brian Groombridge and the World Conservation Monitoring Centre, GLOBAL
BIODIVERSITY: STATUS OF THE EARTH'S LIVING RESOURCES. London and New York:
Chapman and Hall, 1992. 585 pages, an oversized volume. $ 59.95 hardbound.
With sponsorship by the leading world conservation organizations. With a
section on "Valuing Biodiversity."
--Whit Gibbons, KEEPING ALL THE PIECES: PERSPECTIVES ON NATURAL HISTORY
AND THE ENVIRONMENT. Washington: Smithsonian Institution Press, 1993. 208
pages. $ 16.96, paper. The greatest insult we humans are inflicting on the
environment in the ongoing and massive loss of global biological diversity.
Why and how we must all become involved in keeping all the pieces.
--ENVIRONMENTAL CRIMES AT THE ROCKY FLATS NUCLEAR WEAPONS FACILITY. HEARINGS
VOL. I. U. S. Subcommittee on Investigation and Oversight, Committee on
Science, Space, and Technology. 1,700 pages (!) of testimony before this
House Committee concerning Rockwell Corporations management of Rocky Flats,
a nuclear weapons facility in Colorado. Government documents, call no: Y4.SCI
2:no. 102/163DOC.
--John S. Kennedy, THE NEW ANTHROPOMORPHISM. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge
University Press, 1992. 208 pages. Paper, $ 17.95. Anthropomorphism still
lurks under different disguises; scientists constantly slip into anthropomorphism
in researching and interpreting animal behavior. Some examples, now rather
well exposed, are "search image," "trail-following,"
and "grammatical language." Others, not yet realized to be erroneous,
are "goal- directedness, self-awareness, cognition, and suffering."
Kennedy was formerly at the University of London.
--Richard C. Primack, ESSENTIALS OF CONSERVATION BIOLOGY. Sunderland, MA:
Sinauer Associates, 1993. 475 pages. $ 28.95 hardbound. The first unified
introduction to the science of conservation biology. Part III is on "The
Value of Biological Diversity" and includes a chapter, "The Ethical
Value of Biological Diversity." The opening chapter, "What Is
Conservation Biology?" contains a "Statement of Ethical Principles."
Primack is in the biology department, Boston University.
--Gary K. Meffe and C. Ronald Carroll, PRINCIPLES OF CONSERVATION BIOLOGY.
Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates, forthcoming 1994. With 55 contributors,
many doing chapters, many doing short box essays. For upperclass use, in
contrast to the preceding which is for introductory use. J. Baird Callicott
writes chapter 2, "Philosophy and Ethics of Conservation." Some
short essays: Susan Bratton, "Monks, Temples, and Trees: the Spirit
of Biodiversity"; Roderick Nash, "Discovering Radical Environmentalism
in Our Own Cultural Backyard: From Natural Rights to the Right of Nature";
Holmes Rolston, "Duties to Endangered Species," David Orr, "Liberalizing
the Liberal Arts: From Domination to Design"; Phil Pister, "Agency
Multiple-Use Conflicts"; Frederick FerrÇ, "The Post-modern
World"; Eric Katz, "A New Vision: Humans and the Value of Nature."
Meffe is at the Savannah River Ecology Laboratory in South Carolina; Carroll
is at the University of Georgia in ecology.
--Eugene P. Odum, ECOLOGY AND OUR ENDANGERED LIFE SUPPORT SYSTEMS. Second
edition. Sunderland, MA: Sinauer Associates, 1993. 329 pages. $ 18.95 pages.
The revision includes more emphasis on a holistic, big-picture look at ecology,
global scales. The epilogue includes sections on "Environmental Ethics
and Aesthetics," "Dominion vs. Stewardship," and "An
Ethics Survival Model." Odum is distinguished professor emeritus of
ecology at the University of Georgia.
--David M. Gates, CLIMATE CHANGE AND ITS BIOLOGICAL CONSEQUENCES. Sunderland,
MA: Sinauer Associates, 1993. 280 pages. $ 18.95. Gates believes that reliable
theory data show that within a century the planet will be warmer than at
any time in the past 120,000 years. He projects dramatic impacts. Gates
is professor emeritus of biology at the University of Michigan.
--Frank B. Golley, A HISTORY OF THE ECOSYSTEM CONCEPT IN ECOLOGY: MORE THAN
THE SUM OF THE PARTS. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1993. 353 pages.
$ 30.00. The development of the ecosystem concept in the late nineteenth
and early twentieth centuries. How ecosystem studies dominated ecology in
the 1960's and became a key element of the International Biological Program
biome studies in the United States. How current research uses the ecosystem
concept. Golley is research professor of ecology, University of Georgia,
and former president of the Ecological Society of America. He is also on
the faculty of environmental ethics at the University of Georgia.
--Earl R. Winkler and Jerrold R. Coombs, APPLIED ETHICS: A READER. Oxford,
UK and Cambridge, MA: 1993. Contains a section on environmental ethics:
Holmes Rolston, III, "Values in and Duties to the Natural World";
Lori Gruen, "Re-valuing Nature"; Dale Jamieson, "Ethics,
Public Policy, and Global Warming" and Peter Danielson, "Morality,
Rationality, and Politics: The Greenhouse Dilemma." This adds to a
list of a dozen or more anthologies in applied ethics with sections on environmental
ethics. Winkler and Coombs are in philosophy and education at the University
of British Columbia.
--Becky Malecki, SPIRITUAL BENEFITS OF WILDERNESS, a M. S. thesis completed
in the Department of Human Development, Colorado State University, spring
1993, with a principal advisor Beverly Driver, United States Forest Service,
Rocky Mountain Forest and Range Experiment Station, Fort Collins.
--Jane Kneller, "Beauty, Autonomy and Respect for Nature," a paper
presented at "L'Esthetique de Kant," Centre Culturel International
De Cerisy la Salle, in Normandy, France, June 15-21, 1993. Aesthetics was
earlier much concerned with nature, subsequently mostly concerned with artifacts,
and today there is a renewed interest in nature. Natural beauty is the centerpiece
of Kant's account, and there is the possibility of an account of intrinsic
value in nature. On the other hand Kant claims that nothing is valuable
in itself except the morally good will, and Kant can seem a pillar of anthropocentrism.
Kneller argues for a nuanced account by which Kant does value nature for
nature's sake, though there is a tension in Kant's thought with respect
to nature's value in itself and the absolute value of the good will. She
finds what "looks for all the world like an avowal of his belief in
the intrinsic value both of external nature and the inner moral realm. Kant's
account of the experience of the beautiful is perhaps best seen as his attempt
to work out precisely this tension." Kneller is in the Department of
Philosophy, Grinnell College, Grinnell IA 50122.
--Michael Tobias, LIFE FORCE: THE WORLD OF JAINISM. Berkeley, CA: Asian
Humanities Press, 1992. Paper, about $ 10. With much attention to Tobias'
experience with Jainism and ecology.
--David Rothenberg, HAND'S END: TECHNOLOGY AND THE LIMITS OF NATURE. Berkeley:
University of California Press, 1993. 299 pages. Hardcover, $ 29.95. More
details later.
--Dave Foreman's BOOKS OF THE BIG OUTSIDE lists over 400 books, with annotated
descriptions, also maps, cassette's and CD's, is issued quarterly, and is
a valuable resource bibliography. Ned Ludd Books, P. O. Box 85190, Tucson,
AZ 85754-5190.
--"Just for Kids: You and Your Environment." Special section in
NEWSWEEK, March 29, 1993. "The biggest challenge for our world and
what kids can do about it."
Issues
George Brown, Jr., Democrat from California, the influential chair of the
U. S. Congress (House) Science, Space, and Technology Committee, addressed
the annual American Academy of Science and Technology Policy Colloquium
last spring: "Global leadership in science and technology has not translated
into leadership in infant health, life expectancy, rates of literacy, equality
of opportunity, productivity of workers, or efficiency of resource consumption.
Neither has it overcome failing education systems, decaying cities, environmental
degradation, unaffordable health care, and the largest national debt in
history." "Basic human needs--elemental needs--are intrinsically
different from other material needs because they can be satisfied. Other
needs appear to be insatiable, as the consumption patterns of the United
States clearly demonstrate. ... Once basic human needs are met, satisfaction
with our lives cannot be said to depend on the amount of things we acquire,
use, and consume. ... More technology-based economic growth is not necessary
to satisfy humanity's elemental needs, nor does more growth quench our thirst
for consumption. In terms of the social contract, we justify more growth
because it is supposedly the most efficient way to spread economic opportunity
and social well-being. I am suggesting that this reasoning is simplistic
and often specious." Cited in SCIENCE, May 7, 1993, p. 735.
The world's largest group of professional foresters is urging a dramatic
departure from the century-old practices of the U. S. timber industry. The
Society of American Foresters has received the "Task Force Report on
Sustaining Long-term Forest Health and Productivity." The report says
that the current aim to cut trees at the same rate of regrowth is not enough
to protect forests and forest values over time. "Traditional sustained-yield
management as historically practiced ... is not by itself sufficient for
sustaining ... long-term forest health and productivity" (p. xx). The
report insists on ecosystem oriented management, including the management
of both public and private forests integrated into regional forest systems.
Logan Norris, the task force chair and head of the Forest Science Department
at Oregon State University, says: "We are talking about a major change
in forestry in the United States" Frances Hunt, a SAF member, says:
"If you read [the report] between the lines, what it is saying is that
what the profession was taught, and what it helped teach, has turned out
to be wrong and we are going to have to make amends for past mistakes."
Copies of the 83 page report are available for $ 12 from Society of American
Foresters, 5400 Grosvenor Lane, Bethesda, MD 20814-2198.
Universal human rights? The World Conference on Human Rights was held in
June in Vienna, with delegates from 168 nations, the first such conference
in 25 years. There were also nearly 1,000 advocacy groups present. A main
issue was whether there are transcultural human rights, standards to which
all peoples and nations should be held. China, Burma, Yemen, Cuba, Syria,
Iran, Libya and others claimed that human rights do not reflect a discovery
of universal moral principles, since there are no such things, but are the
cultural creation of Western religious and political traditions and that
no one has the right to impose on them. China's deputy foreign minister
argued for the moral sovereignty of each culture and against the view that
individual rights should and could ever prevail over those of state and
society. The pluralist and culturally particular arguments were often remarkably
like (and sometimes appealed to) those currently popular among multiculturalists
and relativists in U. S. universities--that morals are internal to particular
cultural, historical, and narrative traditions. This claim was for variety,
pluralism, diversity, and multiplicity. Singapore, Malaysia, and Chile,
for instance, argued that in tradeoffs between development and democracy,
development was their chosen cultural focus over democracy. The contrasting
claim, a hope for many at the conference and argued by the United States
and many others, was that, despite diversity and multiculturalism, there
are global moral principles, in which basic human rights are foremost, and
that nations can be held to them, and hold other nations to them when negotiating
foreign policy and trade agreements. For a useful assessment, see Max L.
Stackhouse, "The Future of Human Rights," CHRISTIAN CENTURY, June
30-July 7, 1993.
"Takings bills" have appeared on the dockets of 31 state legislatures
in 1993. These bills appeal to the Fifth Amendment of the U. S. Constitution
which says that the government shall not seize property for public use without
just compensation, claiming that various local, state, and federal regulations,
including many that enforce environmental standards, are "takings"
for which the owners should be compensated. Under the prevailing legal interpretation,
such regulations constitute police power, which prevents landowners from
doing public harm, and do not constitute takings. Delaware is the only state
that has an active takings law; one was passed in Arizona, but citizens
gathered 70,000 signatures to block implementation until voters decide the
bill's fate in November 1994. Such a bill was defeated in Wyoming.
Extinction of smallpox virus? The International Congress of Virology in
Scotland will debate the issue this summer, with 5,000 virologists, although
the World Health Organization and U. S. and Russian authorities have already
recommended destroying the virus. Most see it as a great human achievement;
a few as an act of arrogance. The last stocks are held in two laboratories,
one a Center for Disease Control laboratory in Atlanta, the other in a Russian
laboratory in Moscow. The last known case naturally transmitted was in Somalia
in 1977 when a cook took in an infected baby in kindness to treat it. The
baby died, though the cook survived, today disfigured by the disease. In
a medical accident, an English photographer contracted the disease in 1978
and died. Most favor its extinction, though some argue that the virus, which
is remarkably complex and exists in some 600 strains, has not yet been sufficiently
studied. One problem with further study is that only humans can contract
the disease, and it is unknown why. But testing on humans is ethically impossible.
Biomedical expert Arthur Caplan says, however, "Smallpox doesn't look
like it's done anybody any good in the history of humankind. But it seems
to me we would be too arrogant and too shortsighted if we just assumed that
the creatures that tried to kill us would forever be our enemies."
The disease has been a scourge for centuries. It ravaged Europe and Asia
periodically and was especially virulent in the New World, where American
Indians had little natural resistance to it. Some predict the polio virus
will be next, being made extinct about the year 2010. Story in LOS ANGELES
TIMES, May 18, 1993.
Three persons have been killed recently by wildlife in South Africa, two
by elephants and one by a lion, in each case by recently translocated animals.
Some biologists say that culling and translocating animals is more stressful
than commonly thought, disrupting animal social patterns. Animals are managed
to control numbers, but also because the 9,000 game ranches in South Africa
often want elephants, leopards, lions, rhinoceros, and hippopotamus for
the benefit of their tourists.
The South African government, through the Environment Minister, has announced
plans to introduce or amend 15 laws for better environmental regulation,
for example: provisions working toward a bill of rights for satisfying the
reasonable environmental aspirations of all South Africans.
Animal sacrifice remains more common than once realized among South African
blacks, primarily to propitiate ancestors, typically involving goats, sheep,
bulls, and cows, with the method of slaughter requiring stabbing and letting
the blood flow because this pleases the ancestors. (Thanks for the above
three items to Willem A. Landman, Philosophy, University of the Western
Cape.)
Fragmentation is worse than thought in Brazil's Amazon. A recent study shows
that the deforestation rate is down, but that the fragmentation effects
of what has been cut are more extensive than thought, with, presumably,
a more adverse effect on species extinction. Story in SCIENCE (David Skole
and Compton Tucker, "Tropical Deforestation and Habitat Fragmentation
in the Amazon: Satellite Data from 1978 to 1988," June 25, 1993, and
summary story in NEW YORK TIMES, June 29, 1993.
A Montana rancher, named Shuler, shot and killed a grizzly bear, that, he
claims, was attacking first his sheep and later himself. But the Interior
department assessed him a $ 7,000 fine for violating the Endangered Species
Act, "taking" an endangered species. The court reduced the fine
to $ 4,000, but found that Shuler partially at least provoked the attack.
Killing endangered species is permitted in self-defense but not in defense
of one's property. Opponents of the Act are claiming that this constitutes
a government "taking" of private property under the Fifth Amendment
to the U. S. Constitution, since the rancher was prevented from protecting
his property by federal law. The case is on appeal by the Mountain States
Legal Foundation. Story in WALL STREET JOURNAL, June 23, 1993.
U. S. President Clinton has said that he will sign the UNCED Biodiversity
Convention that former President Bush notoriously refused to sign in Rio
de Janeiro summer 1992. The pact has been signed by 150 nations, though
so far only ratified by 14 nations. It goes into effect with ratification
by 30 nations.
Dispute about the Exxon Valdez. Two groups of scientists, one researchers
at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and the other
researchers funded by Exxon have disagreed intensively about how to interpret
data about the extent of damage that can be traced to the Valdez spill.
At issue is how to interpret a "fingerprint" of oil in Alaskan
fish and wildlife as to its source. Exxon scientists say that little of
the oil is from the Valdez; NOAA scientists say much of it is; Exxon scientists
say the NOAA scientists do not know how to interpret their own data. Up
to $ 2.4 billion in damage claims is at stake, in trials starting this summer.
Story in SCIENCE, May 7, 1993.
The G-77 nations met May 10-21 in Nairobi, Kenya, in follow-up to the Rio
de Janeiro conference. There was debate over spending priorities and complaint
that the G-7 nations were not contributing adequate funds. The G-77 want
to reshape spending priorities toward freshwater resources, housing, and
poverty reduction, but the G-7 nations are concerned with oceans, climate,
biodiversity and environmental conservation. The G-77 nations said that
zero UNEP dollars should be spent on climate, which most interpreted as
a protest to make a point, others said UNEP was not the appropriate vehicle
for such spending. Southern nations complain that Northern nations have
the final say over how the money they make available is spent. Story in
CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITOR, May 19, 1993.
Earth Day and Debate. Public schools are increasingly using Earth Day to
teach environmental awareness, with direct support by the Environmental
Protection Agency (EPA) and other federal agencies. But some protest: Jonathan
Adler, an environmental policy analyst at the Competitive Enterprise Institute,
Washington, says that much of this environmental education amounts to "curricula
of half-truths and political advocacy." It represents "political
indoctrination." Story in CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITOR, April 19, 1993.
NAFTA requires EIS. Federal District Judge Charles Richey has ruled that
the North American Free Trade Agreement is illegal unless the U. S. government
produces an environmental impact statement before submitting the pact to
Congress. The National Environmental Policy Act (1969) requires an EIS for
"every recommendation or report on proposals for legislation and other
major federal actions significantly affecting the quality of the human environment."
U. S. owned companies operating in Mexico can increase their profits up
to 200% by not complying with environmental law in Mexico, much less abiding
by U.S. standards. Former President Bush claimed the pact did not need an
EIS; President Clinton (while campaigning) that it did need one, but since
becoming president has tried to address the environmental issue with "side
agreements." Environmentalists hope to extend this ruling to GATT (General
Agreement on Tariffs and Trade). Story in CHRISTIAN SCIENCE MONITOR, July
2, 1993.
Recent and Upcoming Events
--July 2-5. International Jain Convention, Pittsburgh. With a panel on "Jainism
and Ecology," organized by Michael Tobias. Participants: Jerry Brown
(former governor of California); David Rothenberg, New Jersey Institute
of Technology; Michael W. Fox, Humane Society; Peter Gerard, Animal Rights
Network; Nick Stonington, Merrill-Lynch Company; Atul Shah, Young Jain Society,
and others.
--July 9-11. Ecotheology and Religious Education Workshop, Denton, TX. Sponsored
by the journal ENVIRONMENTAL ETHICS and the Center for Environmental Philosophy
at the University of North Texas. Speakers are Susan Power Bratton, James
A. Nash, Max Oelschlaeger, Eugene C. Hargrove, and George A. James. Contact
Eugene C. Hargrove, Department of Philosophy, University of North Texas,
P. O. Box 13496, Denton, TX 76303-3496. Phone 817/565- 2727.
--July 19-26. "The Ecological Crisis: Rights, Obligations and Opportunities."
At Ghost Ranch, a Presbyterian Conference Ground, Abiquiu, New Mexico. Symposium
led by Joan Martin-Brown, United Nations Environment Programme, Washington;
Wes Granberg Michaelson, coordinator of the World Council of Churches involvement
in the 1992 UN Earth Summit; and William Somplatsky- Jarman, associate for
environmental justice, Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.). Contact Ghost Ranch,
HC 77, Box 11, Abiquiu, NM 87510- 9601. Phone 505/685-4333.
--July 20-22. Royal Institute of Philosophy Conference, Philosophy and the
Natural Environment, Cardiff, Wales. See details earlier.
--July 29-August 1. "A New Generation for Animal Rights." Conference
at Rutgers University, New Brunswick Campus, New Brunswick, NJ. Numerous
speakers, including Tom Regan. Numerous workshops. With a particular interest
in creating a national student organization for animal rights, and a special
appeal to students and teachers. Contact Lisa Finlay, A New Generation for
Animal Rights, 209 N. Graham Street, Chapel Hill, NC 27516. Phone 919/942-6909.
Fax 9191/942-3875.
--August 1-14. Applied Deep Ecology, Philo, California. 2 week summer school
course, in association with the Sierra Institute and the California Institute
of Integral Studies. Faculty include Bill Devall, Susan Griffin, Ed Grumbine,
David Abram, Alan Drengson, Bill Moyers and others. The location is a retreat
center two and a half hours north of San Francisco. Cabins and camping are
available. Contact: Institute for Deep Ecology Education (IDEE), Box 2290,
Boulder, CO 80306. Phone 303/939- 8398.
--August 6-9. Caring for Creation: A Christian Perspective on the Environment.
American Scientific Affiliation Annual Meeting, Seattle Washington. Contact
ASA, P. O. Box 668, Ipswich, MA. Phone: 508/356-5656.
--August 15-18. Workshop on Creation Spirituality and the Rebirth of Nature,
Cortes Island, BC, Canada. Contact Holyhock, Box 127, Manson's Landing,
Cortes Island, BC, Canada VOP 1KO. Phone 604/935-6533.
--August 12-18. The Community, The Family, and Culture, Conference of the
Institute for Advanced Philosophic Research, Estes Park, Colorado. With
papers on environmental issues. Contact Dr. Nancy E. Snow, Program Chair,
Marquette University, Department of Philosophy, 132 Coughlin Hall, Milwaukee,
WI 53233. Phone 414/288-3670.
--August 14-16. International Society for Value Inquiry, in Helsinki, --August
17-20. Tenth International Social Philosophy Conference, in Helsinki. Details
earlier.
--August 20-26. Ecology and Ethics Symposium. Papers invited. Send inquiry
and proposal to Rev. Nigel Cooper, 40 Church Road, Rivenhall, Witham, Essex
CM8 3PQ, U.K.
--August 22-28. 19th World Congress of Philosophy, Moscow. With ISEE Sessions.
See details earlier.
--August 24-26. Creating a Forestry for the 21st Century: An Interdisciplinary
Symposium, Portland Oregon. A conference on the wave of change sweeping
over forestry. Numerous sponsoring institution, including Oregon State University,
University of Washington, the U.S. Forest Service New Perspectives in Forestry
Programme, and others. Contact: Washington State University Conferences
and Seminars, 7612 Pioneer Way East, Puyallup, WA 98371. Phone 206/840-4575.
--August 21-September 2. 1993 Templeton Symposium: Science and Religion:
Two Ways of Experiencing and Interpreting the World. University of Chicago
and Lutheran School of Theology at Chicago. Includes William Klink (University
of Iowa), "Eschatology and Ecology"; Philip Hefner (Lutheran School
of Theology at Chicago), "Can Nature Truly Be our Friend?"; Karl
Peters (Rollins College), "Scientific Theology and Spirituality: How
I Experience God in the World of Nature." Contact: Chicago Center for
Religion and Science, 1100 East 55th Street, Chicago. IL 60615-5199. Phone
312/753-0671.
--September 20-22. Partnerships for Change, an international conference
hosted the United Kingdom, at Manchester. There are many themes concerning
environment and sustainable development. Contact Helen Jones, Room A 302,
Romney House, 43 Marsham Street, London, SW1P 3PY, United Kingdom. Phone
071 276 8168. Fax: 276- 8861.
--September 24-October 1. 5th World Wilderness Congress, in Norway, with
ISEE session on wilderness. See details earlier.
--September 22-25. Conference on Persons, St. Mary's College, Notre Dame,
Indiana. "The Nature of Persons and the Relevance of Personal Modes
of Being to our Understanding of Reality, Ethics, and the Environmental
Crisis." Contact: Patricia Sayre, Philosophy, Saint Mary's College,
Notre Dame, IN 46556.
--October 1-2. Society for International Development, North American Regional
Conference, at Fort Collins, Colorado. Paper and proposals invited, through
August 1, especially on ethics, environmental conservation, and sustainable
development. Contact Maurice L. Albertson, Civil Engineering Department,
Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523.
--October 1-3. Eighth Annual International Compassionate Living Festival
(continuing earlier "Triangle Animal Awareness" Festivals), in
Raleigh, NC. Contact: Culture and Animals Foundation, 3509 Eden Croft Dr.,
Raleigh, NC 27612. Phone 919/782-3739.
--October 5-6, Nobel Conference XXVIX, "Nature Out of Balance: The
New Ecology," Gustavus Adolphus College, Saint Peter, MN. See details
earlier.
--November 4-6. "Biological and Cultural Diversity Challenges in Environmental
Ethics," the Morris Colloquium, University of Colorado, Boulder. Contact:
Dale Jamieson, Department of Philosophy, Campus Box 232, University of Colorado,
Boulder, CO 80309-0232. Phone 303/492-6132.
--November 5-7, Regional Development in the 21st Century: Think Globally,
Act Locally," Naha, Okinawa. Sponsored by the East-West Center, Honolulu,
at the University of Hawaii. Contact EWCA Alumni Office, 1777 East-West
Road, Honolulu, HI 96948.
--November 11-13. National Watchable Wildlife Conference, Corpus Christi,
TX, at Bayfront Plaza Convention Center. Contact: 400 Mann, Suite 909, Corpus
Christi, TX 78401. With many sponsors.
--November 10-13. The Environmental Management of Enclosed Coastal Seas,
Baltimore, MD, sponsored by the State of Maryland. Other sponsors include
the EPA, NOAA, the National Academy of Sciences, as well as international
groups. One associated group is the University of Maryland, through the
Institute for Philosophy and Public Policy. Such coastal seas include the
Chesapeake Bay, the Inland Seto Sea of Japan, the Mediterranean, the Baltic,
the Red Sea, the North Sea, and the Caribbean. Contact EMECS Secretariat,
Coastal and Environmental Policy Program, The University of Maryland, Box
775, Cambridge, MD 21613. Phone 410/974-5047.
--November 11-13. The North American Interdisciplinary Wilderness Conference,
Ogden, Utah. Papers and proposals are invited by August 16, and a book is
planned; a book has resulted from previous conferences. For arts and humanities
papers, contact L. M. Vause, Department of English, Weber State University.
For conference information, Continuing Education, Weber State University,
Ogden, UT 84408-4007.
1994
--January 20-21, 1994. Conference on Ethical Dimensions in U.N. Agenda 21,
at United Nations, New York. Details earlier.
--January 20-22, 1994. Conference on Agricultural Ethics, "Decision
Making and Agriculture: The Role of Ethics." Nova Scotia Agricultural
College, Truro, Nova Scotia. Speakers include Paul Thompson, Frederick Buttel,
Bernard Rollin, and others. Contact Mora Campbell, Nova Scotia Agricultural
College, Truro, Nova Scotia. Phone 902/893-6644.
--March 23-27, 1994. European Conference on Science and Theology: The Concept
of Nature, in Freising and Munich, Germany. Contact: K. H. Reich, PÑdagogischhes
Institut, Rte des Fougäres, CH-1700 Fribourg, Switzerland.
--March 31-April 2, 1994, Pacific Division, American Philosophical Association,
in Los Angeles, with ISEE session. Details earlier.
--April 7-10, 1994. "Rebuilding Security: The Bomb, the Debt, and the
Rainforest," the Peace Studies 6th Annual Meeting, at the University
of San Francisco, CA. Papers and abstracts invited, by January 1, 1994.
Contact: Professor Joseph Faney, Manhattan College, Riverdale, NY 10471.
Selected papers will be published in the PEACE REVIEW.
--April 21-24, 1994. Society for Human Ecology, Seventh Conference, Michigan
State University, East Lansing. There is a call for papers. Contact: Robert
J. Griffore, Dept. of Family and Child Ecology, 107 Human Ecology Bldg.,
Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824-1030. Phone: 571/336-3818.
Fax 336-3845.
--May 5-7, 1994. Central Division, American Philosophical Association, in
Kansas City, with ISEE session. Details earlier.
--June 7-10, 1994. Fifth International Symposium on Society and Resource
Management, at Colorado State University, Fort Collins. Call for papers
extends through November 1993. Contact Michael J. Manfredo, Department of
Recreation Resources, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523.
303/491-6591.
--June 19-22, 1994. lst International Symposium on Ecosystem Health and
Medicine: New Goals for Environmental Management." Organized by the
International Society of Ecosystem Health and Medicine and the University
of Guelph. Proposals due (300 words or less), to Remo Petrongolo, Office
of Continuing Education, 159 Johnston Hall, University of Guelph, Guelph,
Ontario, Canada N1G 2W1. Phone 519/824-4120, ext. 3064.
--September 5-13, 1994. International Conference on Population and Development
(ICPD) in Cairo, Egypt. Contact ICPD Secretariat, c/o UNFPA. 220 E. 42nd
St., New York, NY. Phone 212/297-5222. Fax 212/297-4915. A Preparatory Committee
met May 10-21 in New York, and another Prepcom is in April 1994.
--September 30-October 2, 1994. Hegel Society of America, at the Catholic
University of America, Washington, on the theme: "Hegel and the Philosophy
of Nature." Papers due: January 31, 1994. Contact: Stephen G. Houlgate,
Philosophy, DePaul University, 2323 N. Seminary Avenue, Chicago, IL 60614.
1995
August 1-5, 1995. XIII International Congress of Aesthetics, Lahti, Finland.
Theme: Aesthetics in Practice: Connections between Academic Research in
Aesthetics and Everyday Life, especially Concerning the Environment."
Contact: Sonja Servomaa, University of Helsinki, Lahti Research and Training
Centre, Kirkkokatu 16, 15140 Lahti, Finland.