Tom Booth, The Bear Essential, no. 5 (Spring 1995): 69
With a hint of resignation in his voice, Eugene C. Hargrove, editor in chief of
Environmental Ethics, admits that his journal is not easy reading. Still, for
the serious reader,Environmental Ethics offers the sort of deep thinking that is
lacking in most environmental magazines in the mass media's dumbed-down coverage of environmental
topics.
The latent field of environmental philosophy coalesced with the founding of Environmental Ethics
in 1979 (I publish, therefore I am"). Issued quarterly by the Center for Environmental
Philosophy at the University of North Texas, Environmental Ethics continues
to define the field and to present the work of its leading authors. Its mission,
according to Hargrove, is to provide common ground for people working in philosophy
and environmental affairs. The journal takes an interdisciplinary approach to environmental problems,
drawing contributions in fields ranging from geography to business, theology to
engineering.
The lead article in the spring 1995 issue, "Selling the Nature or Selling Out? Exploring
Environmental Merchandising," by L. M. Benton, analyzes the growing commercialization
of the environmental movement since the early 1970s. Focusing on the Sierra Club and Greenpeace,
Benton raises important questions about the contradictions involved in promoting
an environmental ideology in a consumer-driven culture. Although Benton's arguments might
make you think twice about pulling on your newest environmentally hip T-shirt, her ultimate
conclusions will allow you to wear it with pride and perhaps new insight.
Other articles critique biospherical egalitarianism and explore the idea of respect
in relation to the natural world. The issue concludes with two thoughtful book reviews.
Interest in environmental philosophy is growing: college courses are being offered and books published on the subject. In documenting this philosophic approach, Environmental Ethics gives careful readers new ways to consider and understand environmental issues.